Ontology
what exists · ontological commitment
The study of being qua being — what it means for anything to exist.
In practice
A data model decides whether a 'team' is a real entity or shorthand for a set of people. That choice determines what can be recorded about it, and it is an ontological commitment in Quine's sense.
The common mistake
Treating ontology as a synonym for metaphysics. Ontology asks what exists; metaphysics also covers causation, identity, time and possibility.
Ontology is the study of what exists and of the categories into which existing things fall. It is the core of metaphysics.
The two questions
The first question is what kinds of thing there are. Physical objects are uncontroversial. Numbers, properties, events, fictional characters, holes and possible worlds are all disputed, and the arguments usually turn on whether talk that appears to refer to them can be paraphrased away.
The second is what it means to say something exists. W. V. O. Quine proposed a sharp test in 1948: the ontological commitments of a theory are whatever must exist for the theory's statements to be true. If your best physics quantifies over fields, you are committed to fields. The method converts a metaphysical question into a question about the logical form of your best theories.
Realism and nominalism
The oldest dispute concerns universals. Realists hold that properties exist over and above the particulars that have them — redness itself, not just red things. Plato gave the strongest version with the theory of forms, placing forms outside space and time.
Nominalists hold that only particulars exist and that general terms are devices for grouping them. William of Ockham argued in the fourteenth century that entities should not be multiplied beyond necessity, and that universals are names rather than things.
Aristotle took a middle route: forms are real and exist only in the particulars that instantiate them, which is why his substance is a composite of matter and form.
Modern use
Computer science borrowed the word for a specified vocabulary of entities and relations in a domain. The senses are related — both concern what a description commits you to — and the philosophical question of whether those entities exist is left open by the engineering one.
Concept web
Open the full webQuestions
What is ontology?
Ontology is the branch of metaphysics concerned with what exists and how existing things are categorized. It asks which kinds of entity are real and what existence itself amounts to.
What is the difference between ontology and metaphysics?
Ontology is a part of metaphysics. Metaphysics covers the general structure of reality, including causation, time and identity; ontology focuses specifically on what exists.
What is the difference between realism and nominalism?
Realists hold that universals such as redness exist in addition to particular red things. Nominalists hold that only particulars exist and that general terms are simply ways of grouping them.